Kialo requires cookies to work correctly.
Does pineapple belong on pizza?
Anything can be a made up receipe. 1/4 mud, 3/4 water is technically a receipe, yet everyone would agree that it would make a mediocre dish.
Putting random food together doesn't make one a good chef.
Inedible ingredients do not provide nutrients, which is the basis of food. Edible ingredients when paired with contrasting or harmonious flavors create desirable recipes.
Technically a recipe, but not one that is likely to be in any cookbook or eaten by anyone. So the argument is invalid.